When comparing a clay cloth to a clay bar, there are several factors to consider regarding their effectiveness and usability in car detailing.

Clay Bar

• Purpose: A clay bar is specifically designed for decontaminating the surface of a vehicle by removing embedded contaminants like dirt, tar, and industrial fallout. It is a traditional tool in car detailing.
• Usage: Typically, a clay bar can be used on two to three cars before it needs to be replaced. It requires a lubricant (like detailing spray) to work effectively and can be used in tight spaces.
• Effectiveness: Clay bars are generally very effective for thorough cleaning, especially on neglected surfaces or areas that require more abrasive action, such as wheels.
• 

Clay Cloth

• Purpose: A clay cloth (or clay towel) serves a similar function but is more versatile. It can be used for initial cleaning, buffing, and even cleaning glass surfaces, in addition to decontaminating paint.
• Usage: Clay cloths can be used repeatedly, often up to 50 vehicles, making them more economical in the long run. They are easier to handle and can cover larger areas more quickly than a clay bar.
• Effectiveness: While clay cloths are effective, they may not perform as well as clay bars on heavily contaminated surfaces. They are better suited for regular maintenance rather than deep cleaning.

Conclusion

In summary, if you're looking for a tool for deep cleaning and thorough decontamination, a clay bar might be the better choice. However, if you prefer versatility and ease of use for regular maintenance, a clay cloth could be just as effective for your needs. Ultimately, the choice depends on your specific detailing requirements and how often you plan to use the product.

Here are some images that illustrate the differences between clay bars and clay cloths: